Tax Structure and Performance of Colombian Firms

Borradores de Economia
Number: 
1332
Published: 
Classification JEL: 
D22, D25
Keywords: 
Income tax, Equity, Leverage
Abstract: 

This paper analyzes the tax structure of Colombian firms, which is characterized by a high heterogeneity in effective corporate income tax rates. In particular, we identify the existence of an implicit tax on the size of firms, defined as the change in the effective tax burden associated with different measures of firms’ size. In particular, we find that the effective tax rate of firms varies with the change in firms’ equity. Our findings indicate that this implicit tax is progressive for smaller firms and regressive for larger ones. We estimate the effect of this tax on firm performance using the tax reforms enacted during the period of analysis. We find that, in addition to reducing firms’ equity size, this tax has adverse effects on real investment and generates distortions in financing decisions.

Approach

This paper analyzes the tax structure faced by Colombian firms, characterized by high heterogeneity in effective income tax rates. In particular, it identifies the existence of an implicit tax on firm size, especially when measured through equity. This tax is defined as the change in the effective tax burden associated with changes in various measures of firm size. 
The analysis uses accounting data from all Colombian firms reported between 2017 and 2023, and compares the impact of the tax reforms implemented during the periods 2017–2018 and 2022–2023. The document applies econometric methods to estimate the tax structure faced by firms and to compute the effect of equity on the effective tax rate. It then evaluates the impact of changes in the tax structure on equity accumulation, investment, and indebtedness.

Contribution

The article uses microeconometric techniques to identify, at the level of individual firms, the tax structure they face. Based on this estimation, it identifies a distortion to equity accumulation, defined as the change in the tax burden induced by changes in equity, which has real effects on capital investment. 
The paper contributes to the discussion on the design of the tax structure and the optimal response of firms. More specifically, the results draw attention to the effects of implicit and explicit levies on equity accumulation.

The implicit equity tax is progressive for smaller firms but regressive for larger ones.

Findings

The study’s findings indicate that the implicit equity tax is progressive for smaller firms but regressive for larger ones. In addition to reducing equity size, this tax generates adverse effects on real investment and distorts financing decisions.